Scarpetta Beach at 290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, New York.

This is the tale of 2 nights 2 different experiences. We had a 2-night stay at the beautiful Gurney's. Our first evening at this stunning restaurant, we had Enrique as our waitperson and he was all about "no-can-do", the 2nd night we were lucky to have the sweet and attentive Tiffany as our "can-do" server. My mom has major dietary restrictions so everything we were told couldn't be customized the 1st night, with Tiffany, she made it happen for us the 2nd night, thankfully! Everything was great and the Halibut and Cod were cooked to perfection. The chicken was prepared exactly how my mom requested, she enjoyed it immensely. Our selections did not scream Italian, they were quite light, with subtle references...assuming overall leanings towards the northern region, which was a welcome culinary experience.